As a Malaysian based in Singapore, I put up with my fair share of denigrating comments from ignorant Singaporeans who seem to have an inferiority complex when faced with a person from ‘up north’. I’ve heard all the shit about our rubbishy cars, our universities’ quota system, our lousy education system… the list goes on. Despite (or maybe because of) this mightier-than-thou attitude, I am scarpering back to my own little backwoods country as soon as I legally can. I can’t scarper now because I owe the Singaporean government money, and I have to pay it back in blood. By the manual labour of my brain and four stick-like limbs, I shall absolve myself of the debt after 3 years.
I’ve never had any intention of settling here permanently, but one recent event is the total, final nail. The government’s overly touchy reaction to this illustrates all that is very, very wrong with the way the country is run. I do find it odd that my political views on Singapore (despite not actually having the birthright to comment) run in the same direction as that of the Singapore blogosphere. Perhaps it’s because the blogosphere is populated by more educated and enlightened people than the general populace, hence the overall impression you get from blogs is one of anger, disappointment and sometimes, resignation.
All they needed was one man to be their lightning rod, and to channel all their frustration into words. And he had the mainstream media behind him. Until now, that is. Is the government scared? Perhaps they should be. mr brown has inspired a bit of a fanatical following. I agree with his opinions, since they are well thought out and nicely articulated.
But he is pretty much all I agree with. Reading through the comments, one sees several unwelcome and unenlightened opinions. And this is where I diverge from the crowd.
Firstly, I don’t know how obvious it is to Singaporeans, who live in a multicultural society, that ‘Bhavani’ is a female Indian name. I do concede that sometimes it’s hard to tell, especially with less common names, but I was wading through the comments wondering ‘why are they calling the writer a ‘he’?’
Secondly, perhaps their emotions got the better of them, or Ms Bhavani needs a better editor to clear up ambiguous sentences, but I did not see any insult to mr brown or to his daughter. Several commented that ‘oh that’s a low blow, targeting Faith’ but I didn’t see anything. The offending sentence was about means-testing to see if parents qualified for subsidies for special-needs school fees: “… we understand mr brown’s disappointment, as the father of an autistic child”. I got what they meant. It was the usual political “we feel your pain” line that rings totally empty and insincere, because it’s not as though they’re increasing subsidies, are they? But apparently some people saw more than that. They interpreted it to imply that mr brown was disappointed over his daughter’s condition. Now perhaps some may dismiss my opinion with a ‘my Engrish not so powderful’, but frankly if I had got the erroneous interpretation, I’d reread just to make sure that the government hadn’t suddenly turned into the schoolyard bitch who says ‘I’m so sorry you have a lousy face’. The tide of emotion was running high, I suppose.
I don’t think all this fanaticism is doing mr brown any good. Support is one thing, but myopic (I hesitate to say ‘blind’) admiration is just going to backfire on poor mr brown who will be under more investigation than usual, under suspicions that he is mustering up his own little blogger army or something. So I’ll stay up here, with the fenceposts poking up into my butt. Not as though I have any right to be down there with the protesting masses, anyway. I’m not staying long, remember?
And to pre-empt the flames:
Yes, our cars suck. They suck like the first Japanese cars sucked. Perhaps in 50 years our auto industry will be like the Japanese one too. By the way, the reason our tin-can cars sell so well, is that one of the goals of Vision 2020 is to have a tin-can car in every driveway. Nah, I’m having you on.
I forget if our universities still maintain the quota system, they were supposed to scrap it. Anyway, if the public universities don’t want your business, the private ones do. The private ones aren’t beholden to the quota anyway. Cost is the main reason so many people opt for public universities, and a private education ensures you can’t get married cos you’ll have to pay off your student loan. *gasp* it’s a conspiracy to stop the minority races from taking over the country! *gaspgasp* Actually, I’m tempted to say that most of us don’t care about the quota system (if in fact it’s still in operation) but I have to consider that there are lower-income minority students who are deprived of a place because of that. Never fear, MCA is here! (Malaysian-Chinese inside-joke)
Our education system sucks, because they can’t decide whether to teach in Malay or English. I always figured a bilingual education was cool, but apparently not everyone can handle the code-switching between the two languages. That’s ok, Bahasa Malaysia is looking more and more like English anyway. Case in point: “Aktifkan Akademi Fantasia”. You don’t even have to know Malay to understand that phrase. I’m some sort of demented optimist, so I like to see it as correcting the great error of trying to teach Maths and Science in Malay, rather than indecision. At least they’re doing something for the kids. I remember the adjustment I had to go through when I did A-level Chemistry, because all my info was stored under Malay terms. Now future generations won’t have to suffer like I did! Unless they have lousy teachers who can barely speak English, in which case all I have to say is – you’re screwed. Call me for tuition, RM50 a week. Hahahaha!
We have aged politicians who refuse to leave the stage quietly and instead stand at the sidelines shouting instructions. Hmm, he must be taking a page out of someone‘s book, ahem ahem. Ok, I will give you the point that our old politician is perhaps more of a firebrand who likes talking about explosives and other countries in the same breath, but that’s because that’s his style, mah! Must maintain you know! Rest easy knowing that the current government totally doesn’t agree with him, which is a different situation from elsewhere, no?
If you take offence at the above, then you’ve probably offended me in one way or another concerning the above. If you’ve never said such things to me, then what are you worried about? My argument’s not with you.